Apples are one of the few fruits my kids both agree on, so we go through a lot of them here. For the first few years of the 9yo’s life, I just used store-bought applesauce — which no one but her wanted to eat, of course. Even when you spend the money to buy a premium brand, it’s typically no more than one step above runny and flavorless.
One day, I happened to make homemade applesauce on a whim, and I reminded myself how delicious this treat is. It’s one of those magic foods that’s ridiculously simple to make, doesn’t take too long, and tastes so much better than store-bought that it’s like a different food.
The other thing about applesauce is that there’s not really a recipe for it. Here, I’ve basically written up some notes about how I often make it, but I’m also including options you may want to consider.
Homemade Applesauce Recipe
Makes 4 or so cups
6 large apples*
1/2 c. light brown sugar
1/2 t. cinnamon
1/2 t. allspice
Water
Peel and slice the apples. Here we get into one of your first choices. If you want quick-cooking, fine-textured applesauce, just dice the apples finely. Here, we like chunky applesauce, so I cut the apples into 1/8″-1/4″ slices and let them cook down a bit.
Put the apples in a heavy saucepan — they should no more than half-fill the pan. Just barely cover the apples with water. Dump in the other ingredients. Cover. Bring to a boil, then turn down to a simmer.
Basically, all you have to do now is cook the apples til they look and taste done to you. This takes no more than 30 minutes for me, but your cooking time will vary based on how you’ve chopped the apples. Check the apples every 5-10 minutes, more frequently the longer they’ve cooked. You may need to add water after they’ve cooked a while. They should remain “saucy” — if you let them dry out completely, they’ll burn and stick to the pan. Keeping them covered reduces the need for water, but you may still need to add some.
Once the apples seem very close to being done, have a taste. You may want more sugar or spice. Different apples [even among the same cultivar] will have different levels of sweetness and flavor, based on the time of year and how fresh they are. Always start low on the sugar and spice, and add more toward the end if need be.
Variations
I sometimes add butter. I’m from the South, and everything tastes better with butter. [Really.] I never add more than a couple of tablespoons. But it will make your applesauce richer and smoother.
You can certainly experiment with different spices, too. I recommend sticking with small amounts, and one or two spices total, however. It’s easy to muddle up the flavor. Other spice possibilities:
- Ground ginger
- Cloves
- Nutmeg [Please, only use nutmeg you grate yourself. Easy, and so much better.]
Also delicious: Serve applesauce warm with chopped, roasted nuts on top [or even better: with nuts you've coated in butter, sugar, a tad of salt and then roasted]. My kids typically don’t like nuts in things, so I rarely do this at home.
While the method I describe here will give you delicious homemade applesauce pretty quickly, I also find Edna Lewis‘ theory on cooking to be so true: Cooking long and slow draws out a deeper, richer flavor. So when I think about it, I’ll put apples on very low in the morning and tend them while I go about other tasks in the kitchen.
* The kind of apples you use for applesauce makes a big difference. Please, whatever you do, do NOT use Red Delicious apples for applesauce. As far as I’m concerned, these tasteless, often mealy blobs should be banned from the earth. Oddly, Golden Delicious apples can make a very nice sauce, and they’re good to use if kids are your primary audience: They’re pretty mellow, even though they are significantly more flavorful than Reds. Granny Smiths make a nice tart applesauce, though I prefer them in pie.
My favorite apples for applesauce are Jonathans. I also use Jonagolds when I find them. I’ve used Galas many times for applesauce, though they are a touch too sweet for me personally [but delicious for eating raw for that very reason].